Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Electricity costs in France, EDF becomes a burden for France

AuthorWISE, H.Damveld, Lenoir, Orfeuil
DateMay 1984
Classification 2.02.0.00/53 (FRANCE - GENERAL)
Front

From the publication:

INTRODUCTION

France is often cited as the nuclear leader of the world. With 36 reactors operating 
and 2.5 more under construction, France has the most ambitious nuclear program of 
any nation. Its nuclear plants already produce 48% of the country's electricity and 
plans are to increase this to 82% by the year 2000. French nuclear generated 
electricity is generally believed to be very cheap.

In the recently published book, State of the World- 1984 (Worldwatch Institute, 
1984), Christophen Flavin writes in his chapter on nuclear power economics, that 
"France is a key country in making international comparisons of nuclear economics, 
since the French nuclear construction program has an international reputation for 
efficiency and speed …" Flavin goes on to say that, while it is difficult to draw 
conclusions because of scanty economic data, at least in relative terms, ''the French 
program has been an economic success" (p. 122).

The studies translated here give evidence to the contrary. They show that, while 
Electricité de France (EDF), the highly centralized state- owned utility, continues 
to sell electricity to large industrial users at bargain prices, its own financial 
situation becomes increasingly serious. EDF is operating at a loss and has 
developed huge debts. Forty- four percent (about 70 billion francs) of EDF's debt 
is in foreign currencies. France has the third largest international debt in the world 
(after Mexico and Brazil) with 20% of this due to its nuclear program. In fact, the 
French economy is beginning to resemble the economy of a Third World country, 
since all the money it borrows on the international market goes to service its debt. 
Rather than being an economic success, the French nuclear program is turning into 
an economic nightmare, which threatens the whole of the French economy.

"Electricity Costs in France" by Dutch energy specialist Herman Damveld was 
published in March 1984 as a chapter in the book Kernenergie Uitgeteld, edited by 
Herman Verhagen (Milieu Defensie, Amsterdam). "Ten Years of Nuclear Power: 
EDF Becomes a Burden for France" by Yves Lenoir and Jean Pierre Orfeuil was 
published in the November 1983 issue of Science et Vie. For this brochure, we have 
translated the entire Damveld article and sections of the Lenoir/Orfeuil article. 
Another study on nuclear economics with a chapter on France has been written by 
Jim Harding and will soon be available (in English) from Friends of the Earth, 
104.5 Sansome Street, San Francisco, California 94111, USA.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.