Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
The case against nuclear waste dumping (1990)

AuthorScotland Against Nuclear Dumping
DateNovember 1990
Classification2.05.4.10/24 (UNITED KINGDOM - WASTE - NIREX/NDA DECOMMISIONING)
Front

From the publication:

INTRODUCTION

On 15th May 1990, the Secretary of State for Scotland, Malcolm Rifkind, announced 
his decision to overturn Highland Regional Council's refusal to grant the United 
Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) planning permission to drill two test-
bores at Dounreay in Caithness. The UKAEA had applied for planning permission 
on behalf of the UK's nuclear waste agency, UK Nirex Ltd, who want to test the 
suitability of the area's geology for the construction of a repository for low and 
intermediate-level nuclear waste.

Rifkind 's decision followed a referendum, held by Caithness District Council in 
November 1989, in which 74% of voters rejected the proposals to bury nuclear 
waste at Dounreay. The Daily Record, Scotland's highest circulation newspaper, 
said "Scotland is not Britain's dustbin ... stick it in Trafalgar Square." A House of 
Commons 'Early Day' Motion, tabled by MPs from the Labour and Scottish National 
Parties, deplored the Secretary of State's decision as a "rejection of the 
democratically expressed wishes of the people of Caithness".

The people of Scotland, and Highland Region in particular, are concerned that once 
Nirex have their foot in the door, Dounreay will become a nuclear waste dump for 
the whole world- not only for low and intermediate waste, but high-level waste as 
well. They know that Sellafield's new reprocessing plant, THORP, due to open in 
1993, has two-thirds of its capacity committed to reprocessing foreign spent fuel, 
and that the Dounreay Nuclear Establishment are touting for reprocessing work 
from as far away as Australia.

The Government say that all reprocessing contracts signed since 1976 have 'return to 
sender' clauses, but have admitted that they may keep the lower level waste in this 
country, and send an equivalent quantity, in radiological terms, of high-level waste 
back to the country of origin. No waste has been returned, as yet, to clients from 
Sellafield, and contracts usually stress that client countries must have the 
facilities to accept the waste before it can be returned. How can we be sure that 
any waste will ever be returned?

Nirex currently only have responsibility for the disposal of low and intermediate-
level nuclear waste, but say that after 50 years of cooling, high-level waste could 
be reclassified as intermediate-level nuclear waste. All this adds to a general air 
of mistrust of the nuclear industry and a fear that Scotland is about to end up as 
the world's nuclear dustbin.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.