Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Management of nuclear waste. Report (1999)

AuthorHouse of Lords
DateMarch 1999
Classification2.05.4.10/46 (UNITED KINGDOM - WASTE - NIREX/NDA DECOMMISIONING)
Front

From the publication:

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION

1.1 On 17 March 1997, the Secretary of State for the Environment upheld Cumbria
County Council's refusal to grant Nirex planning permission for a Rock 
Characterisation Facility (RCF) at Sellafield. This "stopped dead in its tracks the 
search for a long-term disposal route for intermediate level radioactive waste" (POST 
Report 106) 1. Since the 1976 report by the Royal Commission on Environmental 
Pollution (RCEP) 2, it has been Government policy to pursue the disposal of solid 
radioactive waste as the long-term solution to nuclear waste management problems. 
The purpose of our enquiry was to see where the rejection of the RCF planning 
application left that policy for the future management of radioactive wastes in the 
United Kingdom.

BACKGROUND

1.2 In 1976 the RCW stated, "there should be no commitment to a large programme
of nuclear fission power until it has been demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt 
that a method exists to ensure the safe containment of long-lived highly radioactive 
waste for the indefinite future". The report continued, "We are clear that the 
responsibility for developing the best strategy for dealing with radioactive waste is 
one for the Government, and specifically for a department concerned to protect the 
environment". It recommended a statutory body, the Nuclear Waste Management 
Advisory Committee, to advise the Secretary of State. It also recommended an 
executive organisation to develop and manage the radioactive waste disposal 
facilities, the Nuclear Waste Disposal Corporation. This latter body would meet the 
cost of rendering wastes environmentally acceptable through charges levied on the 
nuclear industry. The Royal Commission concluded its discussion on nuclear waste 
with the words, "Radioactive waste management is a profoundly serious issue ... 
There must be a clear, identifiable, policy centre and a means to ensure that the 
issues posed by waste management are fully considered at the outset of a nuclear 
programme, not dealt with many years after the decisions on developments that 
lead to the waste have been made and when options may have been effectively 
foreclosed".

1.3 Following the RCEP report, in 1978 the Government set up the Radioactive
Waste Management Advisory Committee (RWMAC). In 1982 it established the 
Nuclear Industry Radioactive Waste Management Executive, which in 1985 became 
UK Nirex Ltd. Neither it nor RWMAC were the organisations envisaged by the RCEP 
report. In 1991, after several years of site evaluation and no little public controversy, 
Nirex selected Sellafield as its preferred option for the site of a deep repository for 
the disposal of radioactive waste. Nirex considered that a precursor of any such 
disposal facility should be the construction of a RCF to investigate in detail the 
conditions in the vicinity and to establish whether they were suitable. It was the 
planning permission for the construction of this research facility which was refused 
in 1997.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.