Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Report on the NIREX internal inquiry. January-December 2000 (2001)

AuthorMurray, Wild, Millard
DateJuly 2001
Classification2.05.4.10/57 (UNITED KINGDOM - WASTE - NIREX/NDA DECOMMISIONING)
Front

From the publication:

1 INTRODUCTION

One of the main tasks Nirex undertook after planning permission for a Rock 
Characterisation Facility at its Sellafield site was refused in March 1997 was to try 
to learn the lessons of that failure. These lessons suggest that the processes required 
to deal with such a contentious issue, the conduct of individuals and the structural 
relationship between organisations all need to change if any progress is to be made. 
Nirex believes that central to these changes needs to be a strong ethical framework 
based on transparency.

One of the first outputs from the analysis of the lessons was Nirex's June 1998 
Transparency Policy (Appendix A). Since then Nirex has continued to develop and 
implement changes to its culture, behaviours and procedures (including the adoption 
of a "whistleblower policy" - "Raising and Sharing Concerns at Work", Appendix B) 
to try and live up to the stated aims in that policy.

It is in the light of this Transparency Policy that Nirex has undertaken an Internal 
Inquiry, of its own volition, during 2000, into allegations made against the 
Company. These are detailed in Appendix C.

Nirex staff members formed the Internal Inquiry team, which investigated the 
allegations. The Nirex Board appointed Lynda Warren, Professor of Environmental 
Law at the University of Wales, as an external assessor. Her terms of reference are 
detailed in Appendix D. Advice was given by Guy Dehn, Director of 'Public 
Concern at Work' and legal advice was taken from Slaughter and May. The 
methodology adopted by the Internal Inquiry team is given in Appendix E.

This report presents the findings of the Internal Inquiry. A number of allegations 
have been substantiated, most are not. The detailed findings from each individual 
investigation of 52 allegations about Nirex and, in particular, the conduct and 
reporting of its Scientific programme are presented in the main body of the report.

Although most of the allegations could not be substantiated, the Inquiry process did 
highlight a number of lessons that Nirex believes it must recognise and implement. 
The emphasis throughout the investigation has been to try to look honestly at the 
ast and to draw lessons rather than conduct a witch-hunt. In this way it is hoped 
that the process will be constructive rather than destructive.

To put the lessons from the Internal Inquiry into context, a strategic analysis was 
carried out comparing the results of the investigation with the general lessons 
learned following refusal of planning permission for the RCF in 1997. This analysis 
is reported in Section 2. General conclusions and recommendations from the 
Inquiry Team are given in the final part of the report.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.