Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Uses of knowledge and values in technical controversies: the case of nuclear reactor safety (1983)

AuthorSteven L. del Sesto
Date1983
Classification3.01.0.20/02 (UNITED STATES - SAFETY)
Front

From the publication:

• ABSTRACT

This paper addresses some sociological and political factors related to the creation, 
use, and control of knowledge and information in technical disputes. This is 
accomplished by way of a content analysis of testimony of pro- end anti-nuclear 
witnesses speaking on nuclear reactor safety before the US Congressional Joint 
Committee on Atomic Energy in 1973-74. The analysis attempts to show how 
competing social groups impose their 'world views' as cognitive, non-evaluative 
definitions of reality, and that some groups are in a better political position to 
achieve this through the use of influence and power. The findings suggest that the 
use of evaluative intelligence in the hearings is a function of location in the 
political process rather than simply a function of group affiliation as such. It is 
concluded that the state of cognitive knowledge itself may play a more limited 
role than we think in determining the kinds of informational inputs to the policy 
process. Future research should concentrate on the ways in which groups and 
individuals succeed in anchoring their claims in culture, socioeconomic 
arrangements, and in political parties, as well as on the ways in which opposing 
groups control the use of knowledge in order to validate their own world views 
as cognitive definitions of the situation.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.