Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Nuclear Sunset. The Economic Costs of the Canadian Nuclear Industry (1996)

AuthorD.Martin, D.Argue
DateFebruary 1996
Classification 3.02.0.00/18 (CANADA - GENERAL)
Front

From the publication:

Nuclear Sunset

1. Introduction

Despite its failure to become financially self-supporting, the Canadian nuclear 
industry promotes itself by stressing its supposed contributions to the Canadian 
economy. The most recent public relations exercise of this nature was sponsored 
by Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. (AECL) and conducted by the consulting firm of 
Ernst & Young. The resulting report, entitled The Economic Effects of the Canadian 
Nuclear Industry, released in October 1993, has been uncritically accepted by many 
federal decision-makers.

The present report, called Nuclear Sunset: The Economic Costs of the Canadian 
Nuclear Industry is a response to the Ernst & Young report, in the area of 
"economic benefits" and AECL subsidies (section 2), and also in the area of 
direct employment (section 3).

Nuclear Sunset also identifies three other topical areas of concern, where AECL 
continues to drain the public purse and put the taxpayer in even greater risk of 
future liability. These areas are AECL 's Isotope Business (section 4); AECL 's 
Decommissioning Liability (section 5); and Federal Heavy Water Investments 
(section 6).

From its roots in World War II as part of the secret allied effort to build the 
world's first atomic bombs, the Canadian nuclear industry has been primarily
a product of government intervention. The Canadian nuclear effort has required
a large investment of public funds - about $13 billion.

In 1952, the nuclear assets of the National Research Council were transferred to 
Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. (AECL), thus keeping the reins of control firmly in 
the hands of the federal government through this wholly owned crown corporation.

In the early years, AECL sold plutonium produced at Chalk River for use in American 
nuclear weapons, to help defray the cost of nuclear research in Canada. The military 
sales were terminated in the mid-1960s, and the focus of the Canadian nuclear effort 
shifted to nuclear power for electricity generation through the development of the 
CANDU reactor.

Early efforts were made to encourage the private sector to take a leading role in 
reactor manufacturing, as had occurred in the United States. However, due to a 
combination of high cost, high risk, and late entry into the international market, 
the industry ended up primarily in the public sector. Private sector companies are 
involved mainly as component manufacturers and consultants- but overall 
coordination, design and construction rested largely with AECL and Ontario Hydro.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.