Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Analysis of Ethical and Assumptions underlying positions of pro- and anti-nuclear intervenors to EARP review scoping hearings (1994)

AuthorEAP, Anne Wiles
DateMay 1994
Classification 3.02.4.10/10 (CANADA - WASTE)
Front

From the publication:

INTRODUCTION

This analysis describes the underlying assumptions that shape the positions on 
nuclear power, expressed by a sample of intervenors to the seeping hearings on 
the high-level nuclear fuel waste disposal concept review. The underlying 
assumptions could also be described as fundamental values, which in aggregate 
form a value system or worldview. The defining values and the logic of these 
worldviews shape people's views of more concrete issues such as the benefits 
and risks of nuclear power.

While perfect agreement was not of course present among the intervenors on either 
side of this debate, there was a striking similarity and consistency in the values 
and concerns expressed by intervenors on each side. That is, each position seemed to 
rest in a fairly established set of values, rather than a variety or random collection 
of values and opinions. The two worldviews were also almost the complete obverse 
of each other: the general picture that emerges is of two relatively coherent but 
contrasting worldviews that come to opposite and conflicting positions on nuclear 
energy and the management of its waste.

The categories used in this analysis were derived from the concerns and values 
expressed by the intervenors, with the result that these categories are not the 
same for the two sides. The ethical positions and arguments are not parallel, a 
characteristic of the conflict that has led to much misunderstanding. The arguments 
of the one side often do not refute those of the other, even though they may be 
made in opposition or criticism. The 'debate' that results is thus confused, 
unproductive, and acrimonious.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.