Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Nuclear Energy: The Real Costs (1981)

AuthorCommittee for the Study of the Economics of Nuclear Electricity
DateDecember 1981
Classification6.01.0.10/19 (COSTS)
RemarksCommittee for the Study of the Economics of Nuclear Electricity, Nuclear Energy: The Real Costs, a special report under the chairmanship of Sir Kelvin Spencer; also published in The Ecologist, Vol 11, No 6, December 1981, pp 253-292.
Front

From the publication:

Chairman's Foreword

This report is offered as a contribution to the analysis of the official case for nuclear 
power stations. It is by a small group of academics uncommitted to any particular 
source of primary energy. In his 1977 series of BBC talks Professor David Henderson 
of University College London stated "it is remarkable how little policy analysis is 
undertaken in Britain outside the official machine." (Listener, 24.11.77). We hope 
this effort of ours will be welcomed as an attempt, however inadequate, to remedy 
this.Since 1977 there have been a few independent analyses of the sort Professor 
Henderson seems to have had in mind. But they have been few indeed in comparison 
with the many official bodies who, because of past commitments and actions, have 
failed to impress the reader with their impartiality.
If wise choices are to be made among a bewildering number of energy strategies 
the formation of policy must be guided not only by officialdom, acting behind 
closed doors, but by all competent to make a worthwhile contribution. Hence this 
report.We make no claim for infallibility. On the contrary, we know our report is 
open to criticism at many points. Criticism, if unbiased and constructive, will be 
welcome. But we have no wish and no intention of being caught up in the fanatical 
polemics which bedevils the subject today.
Our committee mainly consists of academics wedded to the tradition of integrity in 
study and research which has always been the lifeblood of universities. We know 
we must have fallen short of this ideal in many places. In mitigation we plead that 
the withholding of information by the Establishment is partly to blame.
That there have been grave mistakes in energy policy is abundantly clear from the 
criticisms made in such reports as the First Report of the House of Commons Select 
Committee on Energy, and the Report on the Central Electricity Generating Board by 
the Monopolies and Mergers Commission. I reproduce a few of these to emphasise 
the need for many more studies by independent bodies of academic standing.
As chairman of the group I pay tribute to the members who gave unstintingly of 
their time, money, and mental energy; and this was often at considerable personal 
inconvenience. I especially pay tribute to Peter Bunyard. On him fell the burden 
of drafting the report and nurturing it through its many stages.

Sir Kelvin Spencer,
Chairman, C.S.E.N.E.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.