Laka Foundation

Publication Laka-library:
Power propaganda (1980)

AuthorCharles Komanoff
DateMarch 1980
Classification6.01.0.10/46 (COSTS)
Front

From the publication:

Introduction and Summary

In May 1979, the Atomic Industrial Forum, the trade association of nuclear 
manufacturers, constructors and utilities, published its annual survey of 
electricity generating costs at U.S. power plants. The survey concluded that 
nuclear plants had an average generating cost of 1.5¢ per kilowatt-hour in 1978, 
while coal-fired plants had an average cost of 2.3¢/kWh.
In its accompanying press release, the AIF stated that 43 out of the 48 U.S. 
utilities owning or operating nuclear plants were represented in the survey. Thus, 
the survey appeared to be a fairly comprehensive account of the relative economic 
performance of nuclear and coal-fired plants.
For this reason, and because no competing figures were available, the AIF figures 
have been accepted as authoritative, and have been widely cited as evidence that 
nuclear power is currently a significantly less expensive source of electricity than 
coal. They have been reported in the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, 
Time, and Science, among other publications. The figures continue to be quoted 
by the AIF and the Edison Electric Institute, and in many utility industry 
advertisements and other literature advocating increased use of nuclear power.
The AIF data do not provide a fair comparison of the current costs of nuclear and 
coal power. As we show below, they drew upon fewer than two-thirds of U .S. 
commercial power reactors, not nine-tenths as implied by the AIF. Moreover, the 
AIF omitted the plants with the highest construction costs and the worst performance. 
The 21 omitted reactors cost an average of 60 percent more to construct, and 
produced 19 percent less electricity per unit of capacity, than the 39 reactors 
included in the AIF sample. As a result, the average generating cost of the omitted 
reactors was 70 percent greater than that of the survey reactors.This remarkable 
instance of bias is not the only defect in the AIF survey. The survey also:

• failed to make sufficient allowance for nuclear waste and decommissioning costs;

• excluded lower-cost coal plants operated by the country's two largest coal-burning 
utilities (American Electric Power and the Tennessee Valley Authority) because their 
nuclear plants were not included; and

• penalized other coal-fired plants for being used below their potential capacity 
due to excess generating reserves.

This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.