Publication Laka-library:
La Hague Particularly Exposed to Plane Crash Risk (2001)
| Author | WISE Paris |
| Date | September 2001 |
| Classification | 6.02.0.00/05 (NUCLEAR TERRORISM - GENERAL) |
| Front | ![]() |
From the publication:
WISE-Paris Briefing La Hague Particularly Exposed to Plane Crash Risk 1. Summary The 11 September 2001 attacks against the World Trade Center and the Pentagon also hit the classical risk assessment procedures. In the case of nuclear facilities, it clearly appears that the international approach, summed up in France in two Fundamental Safety Regulations (Regles Fondamentales de Sûreté- RFS) applicable to reactors and other facilities, is now out-of-date: it is based on a probabilistic reasoning according to which a very serious risk but very improbable is admitted as «acceptable». For the design of nuclear facilities, this vision resulted in considering only the risk of an accidental crash of small-sized aircraft, several hundred times less significant as far as impact is concerned, and containing only a fraction of the amount of kerosene (or jet fuel) the airliners ‹‹Used» by the terrorists in the United States. In spite of the reassuring tone adopted by the French authorities - contradicted by safety experts in France as well as by specialists of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) - the risk is that of a major accident: besides the fact that nuclear reactors are not conceived to resist a crash of such a scope, building experts agree to say that no construction made either of steel or concrete is guaranteed against the impact of a heavy airplane loaded with fuel. In the case of the containment wall of a nuclear reactor, this could lead to a scenario of releasing radioactivity comparable to that of the Chernobyl accident.
This publication is only available at Laka on paper, not as pdf.
You can borrow the publication or request a copy. When we're available, this is possible for a small fee.

